Is My 1990 HeroQuest Complete? Parts Checklist for Resellers

A component-by-component checklist for the original Milton Bradley HeroQuest (1989 UK/EU, 1990 US). Use it to check a thrift, auction or attic copy before you bid, buy or list it.

Original HeroQuest copies turn up in estate auctions, attics and thrift stores, often in a beaten-up box with "complete?" written on the listing. The box tells you very little. Collectors care about the contents: how many figures, doors and cards are there, and whether the pieces were ever played with.

This page gives you a full count sheet for the original game, a short guide to checking condition, and a fill-in line you can paste into your listing. Print it out, or keep it open while you sort.

A note on accuracy: published inventories for the original game don't fully agree. Card totals in particular differ from source to source, and the 1990 US/Canada release differs slightly from the 1989 UK/European one. The counts below follow a commonly cited inventory of the original game. Always check them against the contents list in the copy's own instruction booklet if it's there. If your copy doesn't match, write down what you actually have, not what the list says.

Step 1: Identify which version you have

Before you count anything, work out what's in front of you:

Write down the copyright year and the language of the rulebook. European copies in other languages are common and attract a different set of buyers.

Step 2: Count the figures (35 total)

Heroes (4)

Monsters (31)

What to check on each figure:

Step 3: Count the furniture (15 pieces)

Furniture tends to get lost into other toy boxes more often than figures do. A missing fireplace or tomb is a common gap, so count carefully.

Step 4: Count the doors (21)

Check each door for bent or creased card and for broken plastic. If the door stands are loose in the box, count the stands and the door pieces separately and note the result.

Step 5: Count the cards (66 in the commonly cited list)

Sources disagree on the total card count, so sort by type and record what you have. If your rulebook lists a different breakdown, go with the rulebook. Look for writing on the cards, bent corners and sun fading.

Step 6: Paper parts, dice and the rest

Unpunched tile sheets and an unused character pad are the clearest signs that a copy was never played. Buyers search for those details.

Step 7: Check the "unplayed / new on sprue" claim

Many auction descriptions say a copy is "never played" or "new on sprue". Here's how to check that before you repeat it in your own listing:

  1. Sprues: are the figures still attached to their plastic frames, or are they loose with small nubs where they were cut off? If they're loose, they've been removed. That doesn't prove the game was played, but you can't call them "on sprue".
  2. Tiles: have any been punched out? One punched tile means you can't describe the copy as unpunched.
  3. Pad and quest book: look for any writing.
  4. Cards: are they still banded, or loose and shuffled?
  5. Inner trays: is the insert intact, or torn or missing?

If you're buying online and can't handle the game, ask the seller or auctioneer for photos of the sprues, the tile sheets and the character pad before the lot closes. If the answer is vague, base your maximum bid on a played copy.

Step 8: Grade the box separately from the contents

A crushed or water-damaged box doesn't make the contents incomplete, and a nice box doesn't make them complete. Describe the two separately:

Buyers who are rebuying the game they had as kids often care most about the figures and the board. Display collectors care much more about the box. Splitting the two in your listing lets each kind of buyer find what they're looking for.

Fill-in listing summary (copy and complete)

Paste this into your listing description and replace the brackets:

Version: Milton Bradley HeroQuest, [1989 UK/EU / 1990 US], [language] rules. Figures: [__]/35. Heroes [__]/4, monsters [__]/31. [All unpainted / X painted]. [On sprue / loose]. Damage: [none seen / describe]. Furniture: [__]/15. Missing: [list or "none"]. Doors: [__]/21 ([__] open, [__] closed). Cards: [__] total. Treasure [__], artifact [__], monster [__], hero spells [__]/12, chaos spells [__]/12, character cards [__]/4. Dice: combat [__]/6, movement [__]/2. Paper: board [condition], rulebook [Y/N], quest book [Y/N, writing Y/N], GM screen [Y/N], character pad [Y/N, about __ sheets left, used Y/N]. Tiles: [unpunched / punched / partly punched]. Missing: [list or "none known"]. Box: [describe corners, tears, tape, fading, odour]. Not included: [anything missing, plus any expansions or extras listed separately].

Title words buyers actually type

Only use the words that are true for your copy:

An honest "incomplete" listing with a clear missing-parts list sells to people filling gaps in their own sets. A "complete" listing that turns out to be short a goblin leads to a return.

Quick pre-bid checklist

Count first, describe second, and price on what's actually in the box.

Sources:

Want the full done-for-you kit?
Dark Tower 1981 Auction Flip Kit: Bid Caps, Condition Test, and eBay Listing Templates ยท $19.00
Get it on Gumroad